top of page
Search

This Election Could Change How Americans See Themselves

Nov 2
4 min read

ALL OF US ARE ON TENTERHOOKS awaiting the outcome of the midterm elections.

 

Here is my prediction about them. It’s not about winners and losers:

 

The most important consequence will have little to do with which party controls Congress. Instead, it will—or at least I hope it will—fundamentally change the story we Americans tell about ourselves.

 

To clarify, here is the story many of us tell ourselves today:

 

We are deeply polarized. We cannot solve the many and serious problems that confront us, from economics to AI. We’re probably doomed.

 

When we do not question this narrative, we disengage from civic life and sink into civic helplessness: We tell ourselves the problems are too big, we have no agency. We withdraw into self-protectiveness. Many of us live in a state of chronic anxiety.



No matter the outcome, many talking heads will interpret the election in the usual way: one side won, the other lost. But I believe this election may reveal something much more important: We the People are making our feelings known.

 

A decisive election won’t mean that meaningful differences have disappeared. But it could expose something the polarization narrative has obscured: Americans across the political spectrum share a profound dissatisfaction with how they’re being governed.

 

Mad As Hell

 

Remember the 1976 movie Network? In one unforgettable scene, television anchorman Howard Beale, played by Peter Finch, looks into the camera and declares, “I’m as mad as hell, and I’m not going to take this anymore!”

 

If the polls are predictive, that may be exactly what Americans are about to say in this election.

 

Going into the election, here are a few things we know from polling about We the People:

 

We are disgusted with political cruelty, dishonesty, and dysfunction.

We are angry about the growing concentration of wealth and power in the hands of a few, while millions of ordinary Americans struggle to get ahead.

We are frustrated with institutions that seem unresponsive to ordinary people.

We yearn for stability, decency, competence, and some sense of common purpose.

We know that the political system itself isn’t working, and we yearn for change.

 

As one data point, consider this:

 

80% of Americans want fundamental change.

 

An October 2026 AP-NORC survey found that eight in ten voters want substantial change or “complete upheaval in how the country is run.”

 

Think about that. Eight in ten voters. And only one in ten feels optimistic about the state of American politics.


This dissatisfaction crosses party lines. Half of Democrats and four in ten independents want nothing less than a “complete upheaval.” Republicans are somewhat less intense in their demands, but 45% still want substantial change in how the country is run.

 

This reveals an electorate profoundly dissatisfied with the status quo.

 

We don’t agree on everything. I’m not saying we do. And whatever might be meant by a phrase like “complete upheaval,” it’s not obvious what might set things right. (It’s certainly not politics as usual!) But most of us perceive ourselves to be at the effect of a system that is exploitative, creates hardship for ourselves and our children, and leaves people feeling powerless in the face of rapid technological and economic change.

 

Of course, wanting change isn’t the same as agreeing about what should change or how. Some Americans want to strengthen institutions that others want to dismantle. But here’s what matters: Beneath our disagreements lies a remarkably widespread conviction that the status quo is unacceptable. That doesn’t make us united. But it may give us a place to begin talking to one another in a fresh, more constructive way.

 

You Are Not Alone

 

The midterms hold the potential to show us something else: We are not alone. Most of our fellow Americans see this, too.

 

Think about what happens when people discover that their frustrations are widely shared. Instead of thinking, “What’s the point? Nobody agrees about anything,” they begin to think, “Maybe I’m not alone. Maybe there are millions of people who want what I want. Maybe we can actually do something about it.”

 

That change in perception can be enormously consequential. People who believe they’re alone tend to withdraw. People who discover that others share their concerns may begin to organize. It’s the difference between resignation and possibility.

 

But what if the election tells a different story? What if we discover that, beneath our disagreements, we see some things similarly? What if millions of us act together to express our dissatisfaction? Then we may realize that we have power, that there are many of us who want fundamental change, and that perhaps we can make it happen.

 

Perhaps I’m wrong about how the election will turn out. Or perhaps the results will be interpreted simply as another partisan victory. But whatever happens, the underlying reality remains: Most Americans are profoundly dissatisfied with the way government works. The question is whether we’ll recognize what that means—and act on it.

 

Wanting change is one thing. Knowing how to bring it about constructively is another. I’ve been learning about some fascinating experiments in democratic governance occurring across Western democracies—citizens’ assemblies, deliberative democracy, and other ways ordinary people are gaining a greater role in shaping the laws by which they live. I’ll share what I’m discovering in subsequent essays.

 

For now, consider this:

 

What if the most important outcome of this election is not who won and who lost, but the realization by millions of Americans that, despite disagreeing about many things, they agree on one very important thing: the way we’re governing ourselves isn’t working? What might become possible?

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page