top of page
Search

Why I’m not high-fiving the 2026 election results

5 days ago
4 min read

  © 2026, Richard McKnight, PhD

  

Democrats won big. Good.

But it’s not a new day in America.

 

A LOT OF LEFT-LEANING AMERICANS are ecstatic over the 2026 midterms. Those of us who voted for Democrats said NO to an immoral, incompetent, reckless administration. We put in place newcomers who promise to put us on a far better path. All this is worth celebrating.

 

But I find myself holding back more than many of my left-leaning friends. Many are high-fiving all over the place. Me? I’m only high-threeing. Maybe high-fouring.

 

Here’s why: I fear we’re confusing historic election results with democratic renewal. The two are not the same thing. Winning elections matters enormously. But renewing democracy matters even more.


 

I hope I’m not being a buzzkill here. I appreciate those who wrote postcards, canvassed, made donations, and mounted voter registration drives. And I totally understand the relief they feel. I feel it, too.

 

But, as they say, elections have consequences, and I’d like to tell you about the some of the consequences of this election for me.


Sobering Numbers

 

There are three numbers that have my attention: 49, 27, and 28.

 

First, only 49% of eligible voters voted. I don’t know about you, but this doesn’t encourage me about the health of our democracy. OK, this was high by historical midterm standards, but half of us who enjoy the benefits of freedom failed to darken the doorway of a polling booth or return a mail-in ballot. One friend challenged my dismay, saying, “But the turnout in midterms is always lower.” Forgive me, but I don’t find this encouraging. We can and must do better than this.

 

Within that 49%, we find the usual pattern: Older people voted in far greater numbers than young people did. In other words, way too many of those whose future is most affected by this election stayed home.

 

What percentage of voters 18-29 cast a ballot this cycle? Keep in mind that this was the second-highest youth turnout in a midterm in the last 30 years.

 

While the numbers are preliminary, Tufts University’s CIRCLE (Center for Information & Research on Civic Learning and Engagement) says only 27% of the youngest voters showed up nationally. Even in a midterm election that produced extraordinary Democratic victories, roughly three out of four young Americans did not vote.

 

I can only hope that those who abstained but now comprehend the consequences of this election will tell themselves that voting matters after all.

 

When I interviewed young people while writing When We The People Lead, The Leaders Will Follow, I heard a variation of the same complaint again and again: “I see no difference between Republicans and Democrats. They’re all the same. My vote means nothing.” It made me feel very, very sad.

 

Those words reflect more than political cynicism. They reveal powerlessness and hopelessness. A democracy cannot thrive when millions of its citizens, especially young ones, believe they have no meaningful role in shaping their future.

 

Let’s Not Break Our Arms Patting Ourselves on the Back

 

Here is the third statistic that has my attention: 28%.

 

According to Tufts, only about 28% of eligible Americans voted for Democratic House and Senate candidates. This means roughly 72% of Americans either voted otherwise or did not vote at all.

 

The outcome of this election, as we all know now, was a history-making Democratic rout. Many of us who lean left and are horrified by the Trump administration are heartened with these results, as we should be.

 

But I’m here to say, “Slow down.” Yes, this was a remarkable Democratic accomplishment, but to me, it does not represent a broad national mandate or anything like a democratic renewal.

 

The morning after the election, a friend said something to me like, “It’s a new day in America.” Another said, “We’re seeing a turning point that brings in a new coalition of voters.” Even NYT columnist Maureen Dowd wrote, “We saved ourselves and our democracy.”

 

I don’t buy it.

 

Yes, those who did vote for Democrat candidates said a loud NO to Trump, a good thing. But before we wear ourselves out high-fiving, let’s put something into perspective: With this election, America has not suddenly turned blue.

 

There are three possible interpretations of this election:

 

·       This was a Democratic Party renewal.

·       This was a repudiation of Trump.

·       This was a genuine political realignment that will endure.

 

Given the colossal swings in voter preference over the short period from 2024 to 2026, I’m putting my money on the second. I would be delighted to be proved wrong, but I’m with Ezra Klein of the NYT: “It wasn’t a realignment election; it was a dealignment election.”

 

The question isn’t whether left-leaners can win elections. They—we—just demonstrated that we can. The question is whether we can build a democracy in which millions more Americans believe they have a meaningful role to play, regardless of how they vote.

 

And please, now that the results are in, let’s not slip back into business as usual: Politicians win elections and go off to govern, leaving voters on the sidelines. Victorious voters, meanwhile, assume they’ve done all that democracy requires of them.

 

Yes, let’s feel heartened. But let’s remember that the most important question isn’t simply who won, or even why they won. It’s whether more Americans are coming to believe that democracy is something we do, rather than something politicians do for us.

 

P.S.—Here is something I am high-fiving: The election of Scott Colom of Mississippi to the US Senate. This was Strom Thurman’s seat. This is a testament to a good candidate and steadfast organizing by a lot of people over a long period of time. Bravo!

 


 

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
When Technology Outruns Our Wisdom

On the one hand, a cooperative society gets an extraordinary tool that can help it do good, individuals get unprecedented creative and intellectual assistance, and businesses—at least theoretically—ca

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page