What If Every Political Campaign Left Democracy Stronger?
POLITICAL FOLKLORE WOULD TELL US that political candidates win because their message was better than that of their losing opponent. If there is any truth in this, it might be instructive to examine the messages of the Democratic Senatorial candidates who flipped Republican seats.
Let’s look at those messages, then ask an even more important question:
Did any of these candidates—using effective messaging or other means—draw voters into a deeper expression of citizenship, or were they all about persuading voters to choose them over opponents?
The distinction matters. Democracies do not flourish merely because citizens choose better leaders every few years. They flourish when citizens themselves become active participants in public life. And politicians can help make that happen, whether they win or lose an election.

Winning Messages
In Kansas, Adam Hamilton emphasized decency, practical problem-solving, and public service. In Ohio, Sherrod Brown championed the dignity of work and an economy that rewards those who create its wealth. Candidates such as Josh Turek in Iowa, Roy Cooper in North Carolina, Troy Jackson in Maine, Annie Andrews in South Carolina, and Scott Colom in Mississippi differed in emphasis, but shared a common message: Government should serve ordinary citizens rather than entrenched interests, and people who work hard should have a fair chance to build a decent life.
There is another common thread worth noticing. These candidates did not merely ask voters to reject Donald Trump or Republican policies. They offered an affirmative vision of what government ought to do, combining a politics of NO with a politics of YES.
The NO—to corruption, cruelty, economic unfairness, and the domination of our lives by wealthy interests—was the stronger message, but there was also a more subtle YES—to decency, opportunity, dignity, affordability, and government that serves the common good.
But James Talarico’s campaign in Texas went a lot further: Using the language of Christianity, it appealed to voters’ moral convictions, not simply their economic and political interests.
The former teacher and seminarian, who won Texas by a stunning 12-point margin, framed politics not principally as a contest between Republicans and Democrats, but between ordinary people trying to live decent lives and powerful interests that profit from keeping them divided.
He grounded his campaign in the conviction that “There is no love of God without love of neighbor,” offering a message that was at once moral, economic, and deeply communal.
Largely Missing: An Invitation
Now, consider what most of these successful candidates were essentially promising: Elect me, and I will work to make your life better.
That is not a bad thing. But my concern is that this is business as usual: Politicians asking citizens to turn over governing to the professional political class. Yes, we need competent, decent, responsive elected officials, and voting for them is an essential responsibility in a representative democracy, but there was an opportunity largely lost here.
Among these candidates, the invitation to Americans to take responsibility for the future of their communities and their country was largely missing. This election, because so much attention was focused on it, was an extraordinary opportunity to awaken a stronger sense of citizenship. It went largely unexploited.
Imagine if the energy that brought Americans to the polls were carried into neighborhoods, congregations, schools, and communities. Imagine neighbors who seldom speak to one another beginning to identify things they care about and working together to improve them.
They would be building relationships, learning to cooperate across differences, and discovering that they can accomplish things together that none could accomplish alone. They would be doing democracy. Even a losing political candidate could foster this.
Politicians: Please Take The Message One Step Further
James Talarico was an exception. He made community service central to his campaign. His volunteers packaged tens of thousands of meals for food banks, organized a statewide “Love Thy Neighbor” food drive, and collected school supplies for children.
These were not simply charitable gestures by a candidate. Talarico was providing opportunities for large numbers of ordinary Texans to work together in service to their communities, making civic participation part of the campaign itself. He made love visible.
Talarico was not alone. In Mississippi, Scott Colom launched a “Mississippi Matters” tour supporting soup kitchens and food pantries, organized a drive for families devastated by tornadoes, and participated in community cleanup efforts.
Both Colom and Talarico offered a glimpse of how political campaigns might do more than mobilize people to win elections. Campaigns might also draw people into the work of serving their neighbors as a matter of course, not just as an election-year thing.
Going forward, perhaps the most important question we should ask of candidates is not simply “What will you do for us?” but “What will you inspire us to do for ourselves and for one another?”
In this lies the possibility that—whether the candidate wins or loses—something changes for the better.
Imagine what could happen if political campaigns routinely awakened a sense of responsibility and compassion that endured long after the votes were counted!
For one thing, we might begin to reverse one of the most troubling developments in modern American democracy: the growing conviction that democracy is something we watch on the news and that improving things is something politicians do for us, rather than something we citizens do together.
Richard McKnight, PhD is the author of When We The People Lead, The Leaders Will Follow and the Project Director of Light Many Fires. He blogs at lightmanyfires.org.
Related blogs:



Comments