top of page
Search

When Technology Outruns Our Wisdom

Nov 9
3 min read

On the one hand, a cooperative society gets an extraordinary tool that can help it do good, individuals get unprecedented creative and intellectual assistance, and businesses—at least theoretically—can become dramatically more productive and innovative.

 

But on the other, the same technology threatens to eliminate or fundamentally reshape millions of jobs, and a surveillance state (e.g., China and, increasingly the US) gets an extraordinary tool that can invade—and is invading—our privacy in very worrisome ways. On top of this, propagandists get vastly greater capacity for misinformation and deception and militaries get autonomous weapon systems that increasingly leave humans out of decision making.

 

Again, the question arises: What happens when extraordinarily powerful technologies are introduced into a civilization still organized substantially around competition, domination, nationalism, profit, status, fear, and distrust?

 

With AI, we step up the threats.

 

Where a nuclear weapon enormously amplifies physical power, AI amplifies cognitive power. With nuclear weapons, we created machines of horrifying destructive force. With AI, we are creating something different: systems that have capacities we once associated almost exclusively with human agency—reasoning, persuasion, planning, creation, scientific discovery, and strategic analysis. And we are learning they can act autonomously.

 

AI changes the equation. With nuclear weapons, it looks like this:

 

Ancient psychology + nukes = existential danger

 

Add in AI and political instability, and the equation becomes a disturbing unknown—a kind of civilizational singularity, a point where technology has consequences we cannot predict:

 

Ancient psychology + nukes + AI + political instability = ?

 

Do I Need to Change My Way of Thinking?

 

Human beings flourish when their ways of thinking and living are aligned with, i.e., adequate to, reality. When reality changes dramatically, we must change with it. This was Einstein’s counsel, Frankl’s, too. Yet as both observed, compared with the challenges required to develop new technologies, changing the human mind, heart, and moral intelligence is vastly harder.

 

As I reflect on all of this, I begin to wonder if my own formulation needs updating. I’ve been saying, “Democracy demands that Americans become more civically engaged.”

 

Maybe that isn’t big enough.

 

Perhaps the next stage of human society—if there is to be one—requires us to become different kinds of human beings: more relational, more cooperative, more responsible, more capable of restraint, and more conscious of our interdependence. These qualities have always been virtues. In a world of nuclear weapons and artificial intelligence, they are becoming necessities.

 

That brings me back to democracy.

 

Democratic citizenship is not merely voting, following the news, being a good neighbor, or influencing government. I am beginning to think of it as a practice that both requires and fosters human development. It requires a certain kind of wisdom—and, practiced well, helps us develop wisdom.

 

Citizenship asks us to listen to people unlike ourselves, cooperate across differences, accept responsibility for something larger than ourselves, exercise restraint, resolve conflicts without bullying, and recognize our dependence on one another. To borrow a metaphor, this is the social soil out of which can grow even more trust and collective agency.

 

Perhaps, then, the case for becoming better citizens is larger than I have been making it.

 

We need to become more capable of democracy because democracy requires wisdom. But we may also need to become more capable of democracy because the powers we have created increasingly require us to become wiser human beings. Today, to me, it seems true that we either do this—and fast—or else. 

 

RELATED:

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page